Relative clauses — who / whom / whose / which (Unit 94)
Pattern
Section titled “Pattern”A relative clause attaches a description to a noun. The pronoun’s job is to stand in for a noun in the relative clause, so the choice depends on what role the pronoun plays, not on the verb tense.
N (antecedent) + [who / whom / whose / which / that + ...]The decision rule
Section titled “The decision rule”Ask three questions in order:
- Is the antecedent a person or a thing?
- Person →
who/whom/whose(neverwhichfor people) - Thing →
which/that(neverwhofor things)
- Person →
- Is the pronoun the subject of the relative clause, or the object?
- Subject →
who(people) /which(things) - Object →
whom(people) /which(things) —whois acceptable in everyday speech
- Subject →
- Does the relative clause need a possessive?
- Yes →
whose(works for people and things;whoseis the only possessive relative pronoun)
- Yes →
Worked examples
Section titled “Worked examples”| Antecedent | Role in clause | Pronoun | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| the couple (person) | subject of “got” | who |
The couple who got married. |
| the couple (person) | object of “I thanked” | whom |
The couple whom I thanked. |
| the couple (person) | possessive of “wedding” | whose |
The couple whose wedding I attended. |
| the car (thing) | subject of “broke down” | which |
The car which broke down. |
| the car (thing) | object of “I bought” | which |
The car which I bought. |
| the man (person) | possessive of “car” | whose |
The man whose car was stolen. |
The common errors
Section titled “The common errors”- ❌ The car who broke down. —
whois for people, not things. - ❌ I met a couple to got married. —
tois not a relative pronoun. - ❌ I prefer working to be on my own. — not a relative-clause error, but easy to confuse; in relative clauses,
tois the infinitive marker, not a preposition. (See: verb + preposition + -ing.) - Mixing up object and subject: The man who I saw is acceptable in speech but
whomis the formal/correct choice when the pronoun is the object.
that as a universal alternative
Section titled “that as a universal alternative”that works in place of who or which in defining relative clauses (the kind that identifies which noun you mean), but never for possessive (use whose).
- The man that I saw. ✓
- The man whose car I saw. ✓
- The man that car I saw. ✗
Source
Section titled “Source”Murphy, English Grammar in Use, Unit 94: Relative clauses 3 (whose / whom / where).